Finding the right complement to your killer new baby pink lipstick or rich emerald shadow can sound like a challenge when there are so many options.

What colors go together? Which ones don’t? We’re here to answer those burning questions.

From summery peaches to vampy dark lips, we’ve put together no-fail lipstick-eyeshadow pairing that’s sure to look fab every single time. But don’t take our word for it, try them out yourself.

Shimmery Taupe + Deep Berry Lips

Berry lipstick is perfect for the holidays, and looks best when it takes centerstage. The best complement to a dark bordeaux pout is shimmery taupe lids.

Brown Shadows + Peach Lipstick

For an easy, everyday look, pair peachy lipstick with browns. You can do a light or neutral brown, or build your shadow for a heavier eye makeup look—the choice is yours!

Pearlescent Whites and Pinks + Fuchsia Lipstick

Sometimes, all you have to do is switch up the tones in the same shade! Bright pink puckers look devilishly chic when paired with a lighter pink lid.